Critters for Sale is made in an unusual style and is accompanied by an unusual visual series. In this case, we are dealing with a graphic novel, which is recommended only for an audience that has reached the threshold of adulthood. It contains a large number of scenes of violent death, such as beheadings and burnings, as well as strangulation. Sometimes what is happening on the screen has a surreal look, as a psychopathic killer might see it. The story is presented using black and white images and videos that are deliberately degraded in quality by superimposing noise on them. The game does not offer one plot, but is divided into 5 unrelated stories.

In Critters for Sale you will have to visit different time periods and universes based on African and Middle Eastern myths and legends. The content contained in them is frightening and attractive with its unknown and mystery. On the way of the protagonists, you will encounter black magic and ancient demons with deadly abilities. The lion's share of the gameplay will be based on conversations interrupted by strange video inserts. You will need to make various decisions that can have a significant impact on the ending. The hero's goal is survival, which is possible only with the right sequence of actions. There will also be a chance to practice searching for objects.